T

The Russian Tea Room

150 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019, USA
New York
Open

Influencer Reviews1

About

Pizzeria Russica is a small, bustling pizza joint located at 85 Canal Street, just outside the shadow of Madison Square Garden in New York City. Known for its hardworking staff and tight quarters, the spot has gained a reputation for its classic New York-style slices and the relentless hustle of its team behind the counter.

The Visit

The reviewer visited Pizzeria Russica for a classic pizza review, encountering a chaotic but authentic New York slice shop experience. Despite delays caused by another customer cutting the line, the reviewer remained honest about the pizza's texture, noting excessive flop on the first slice. After some encouragement from locals and staff, he agreed to a rare instant re-review, trying a fresh slice straight from the oven to give the hardworking pizzaiolo a fair shot.

What They Ate

First slice of cheese pizza (sat in the box for 7-10 minutes)
Second, fresh slice of cheese pizza straight from the oven

Quotes

"All right, pizza review time, Pizzeria Russica, 85 Canal Street, right outside the shadow of the garden."
"This guy is running a tight little operation, can't even move in there, tiny little spot, he's running around, there's no line integrity."
"It's so floppy, that guy was just in the box though."
"I really want to give it a good score, 6.7, Pizzeria Russica, it's just too floppy."
"This guy's working his ass off in there, and you want me to leave at 6, 7. I can't do it."
"Now, everyone's saying this guy's the nicest guy ever, and that's why we're doing it twice."

Our Reflection

The reviewer's experience at Pizzeria Russica captures the unpredictable charm of New York pizza culture. From the cramped, high-energy shop to the chaos of line-cutting and the relentless hustle of the staff, every moment feels authentic. The initial disappointment with a floppy slice is balanced by empathy for the hardworking pizzaiolo, prompting a rare second chance. The community's support for the owner and the willingness to revisit the review highlight the human side of food criticism, where fairness and context matter as much as flavor.

This review includes brief, attributed excerpts of copyrighted material used for the purposes of commentary, criticism, and education. Such use is permitted under Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act. All rights to the original works remain with their respective creators and copyright holders. Our intent is to highlight, celebrate, and help audiences discover these creators by directing attention to their original content.

Google Reviews

0.0
(0 reviews)

Recent Reviews in New York

Discover more restaurant recommendations in New York