Hamburger America
Influencer Reviews4
JOLLY
About
Hamburger America is the New York burger joint opened by George Motz, a renowned burger historian, author, and filmmaker. Motz is celebrated for his deep dives into American burger culture and his signature approach to classic burgers. The restaurant is an extension of his lifelong passion for perfecting the art of the hamburger, offering a menu that honors simplicity and tradition.
The Visit
Visiting Hamburger America with George Motz, the self-proclaimed Burger Scholar, was a memorable experience. The reviewer was treated to a lineup of classic American sandwiches, each crafted with Motz's signature attention to detail. From the acclaimed burgers to the humble grilled cheese and PBJ, the meal showcased Motz's philosophy of simplicity and quality. The atmosphere was relaxed, with plenty of laughter and genuine appreciation for the food and Motz's expertise.
What They Ate
Quotes
"After literally just eating maybe the best burger of my entire life, I'm now sitting here with two bits of white bread and peanut butter and jam."
"But, I mean, this is, this is like all of you going right back to the womb here. Almost to the womb."
"There's no way that has the right to be that good. Is it the butter? The butter and the cheese? I mean, oh my gosh."
"It's simple as hell. Completely simple. But, I mean, it's not supposed to be anything what you're tasting. Hell yeah."
Our Reflection
The visit to Hamburger America is a celebration of culinary nostalgia and expertise. George Motz's approach is refreshingly honest—he strips away the unnecessary, letting the core ingredients shine. The reviewer’s reactions reveal a deep appreciation for simplicity done right, whether in the perfect burger, a grilled cheese, or a PBJ. Laughter and gratitude fill the air, underscoring the privilege of learning from a true burger scholar. This meal is less about extravagance and more about honoring the humble classics that evoke comfort and joy.
This review includes brief, attributed excerpts of copyrighted material used for the purposes of commentary, criticism, and education. Such use is permitted under Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act. All rights to the original works remain with their respective creators and copyright holders. Our intent is to highlight, celebrate, and help audiences discover these creators by directing attention to their original content.
Michael Ligier
About
Hamburger America was opened by George Motz, a renowned burger historian and filmmaker, who has dedicated over 25 years to studying and documenting American hamburgers. Motz is known for his documentaries, books, and deep passion for burger culture. The restaurant serves as a living tribute to classic American burgers, celebrating their history and regional variations.
The Visit
Hamburger America offers a unique burger experience curated by George Motz, a true authority on the subject. The reviewer highlights the restaurant's dedication to authenticity and the evolving menu, which ensures each visit feels fresh and exciting. The space is described as a homage to hamburger history, with George and his team committed to honoring the burger’s legacy. The reviewer’s experience was marked by both nostalgia and discovery, making it a must-visit for burger enthusiasts.
What They Ate
Quotes
"This restaurant is a piece of living hamburger history and his mission is to show people why the humble hamburger is such an important piece of culinary history."
"It's a restaurant where every single time you come back, you can have a new experience."
"(The Classic Smash Burger) It really is so simple… it comes together in a few minutes, and yet it is so packed with flavor."
"(Loose Meat Sandwich) This is the only burger that I’ve ever had where I’ve been served with a spoon because you want to basically grab some of the loose meat and pack it back in as it falls out."
Our Reflection
Hamburger America is more than just a burger joint—it's a living museum curated by George Motz, whose obsession with burgers is both infectious and inspiring. Every detail, from the menu to the atmosphere, reflects a deep respect for the hamburger’s role in American culture. The reviewer’s experience was filled with discovery, nostalgia, and genuine excitement. The rotating specials and classic offerings ensure that each visit is unique, making this spot a pilgrimage site for anyone passionate about burgers and culinary history.
This review includes brief, attributed excerpts of copyrighted material used for the purposes of commentary, criticism, and education. Such use is permitted under Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act. All rights to the original works remain with their respective creators and copyright holders. Our intent is to highlight, celebrate, and help audiences discover these creators by directing attention to their original content.
Danny Kim
About
Hamburger America was opened by George Motz, a filmmaker turned burger expert who has dedicated decades to studying and documenting America's best burgers. Motz is known for his cult-classic film about hamburgers, multiple TV shows, and several books on the subject. The restaurant focuses on simplicity and quality, serving classic American cheeseburgers and regional specialties like the Oklahoma onion burger.
The Visit
Hamburger America stands out in New York City's crowded burger scene by focusing on simplicity and ingredient quality. The reviewer is guided by George Motz himself, who demonstrates the meticulous process behind their signature cheeseburger and the Oklahoma onion burger. The experience highlights the restaurant's dedication to perfecting every element, from the beef blend to the choice of bun and cheese. The atmosphere is energetic, with high daily volumes and a sense of burger expertise throughout.
What They Ate
Quotes
"Simplicity is the number one way to achieve a perfect hamburger. So you have very few ingredients. Because you have so few ingredients, every one of those ingredients has to be perfect."
"This is the cheeseburger all the way. Cheeseburger all the way. It's cheese on a burger, and all the way means mustard, pickle, onion."
Our Reflection
Hamburger America is more than just a burger joint—it's the culmination of George Motz's lifelong passion for the craft. The reverence for simplicity and quality is evident in every step, from the careful selection of beef to the precise assembly of each burger. The energy in the kitchen mirrors the excitement of the city outside, and the sheer volume of burgers served speaks to their popularity. The experience is both educational and delicious, offering a masterclass in classic American comfort food.
This review includes brief, attributed excerpts of copyrighted material used for the purposes of commentary, criticism, and education. Such use is permitted under Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act. All rights to the original works remain with their respective creators and copyright holders. Our intent is to highlight, celebrate, and help audiences discover these creators by directing attention to their original content.
James Andrews
About
Hamburger America in SoHo, New York City, was opened by George Motz, a renowned burger historian, author, and filmmaker. Motz is celebrated for his dedication to preserving America's burger traditions, and his restaurant reflects his travels and research. The menu features classic smash burgers, Oklahoma fried onion burgers, and rotating monthly specials inspired by legendary burger joints across the country.
The Visit
The reviewer visits Hamburger America in SoHo, eager to see if George Motz’s burger expertise translates into a standout dining experience. They sample multiple burgers, including the Oklahoma fried onion burger and a monthly special, and finish with a brownie for dessert. The atmosphere, adorned with burger memorabilia, and the fair pricing both impress. The reviewer finds the food delicious, the staff friendly, and the overall experience fun and memorable.
What They Ate
Quotes
"Hamburger America, in a way, gave me that chance and I wasn't disappointed."
"The burger was simple. I got a double and it contained stewed onions and butter. It was fantastic."
"While burgers are certainly the focus of Hamburger America, the restaurant also offers a small selection of desserts."
"Hamburger America is truly one of the best burger restaurants in New York City."
Our Reflection
The reviewer's enthusiasm for Hamburger America is palpable, from the first bite of a buttery, onion-laden burger to the last forkful of a surprisingly moist brownie. The restaurant’s homage to burger history, through both its menu and decor, creates an immersive experience that goes beyond just eating. The monthly specials, inspired by iconic burgers nationwide, add a sense of discovery and nostalgia. Friendly staff, fair prices, and a celebratory atmosphere make Hamburger America a must-visit for burger lovers. The reviewer’s repeated visits and glowing praise underscore the restaurant’s ability to deliver not just great food, but a memorable, joyful dining adventure. Even minor quibbles, like glass size, are overshadowed by the overall excellence and Motz’s clear passion for the craft.
This review includes brief, attributed excerpts of copyrighted material used for the purposes of commentary, criticism, and education. Such use is permitted under Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act. All rights to the original works remain with their respective creators and copyright holders. Our intent is to highlight, celebrate, and help audiences discover these creators by directing attention to their original content.
Explore Related Content
Google Reviews
0.0(0 reviews)Recent Reviews in New York
Discover more restaurant recommendations in New York